When most people think of the Caribbean, their minds drift to the usual suspects like Jamaica, Barbados, or the Bahamas. These popular destinations certainly have their charm, but they’re also packed with cruise ships and crowded beaches that can make you feel like you’re sharing paradise with half the world.
The Caribbean actually contains over 700 islands, and many of the most spectacular ones remain largely untouched by mass tourism. Here is a list of 16 hidden Caribbean islands that offer pristine beaches, authentic culture, and the kind of peaceful escape that’s becoming harder to find.
Saba
This tiny Dutch island rises dramatically from the ocean like a green mountain peak. Saba spans just 5 square miles, making it one of the smallest islands in the Caribbean, but what it lacks in size, it makes up for in stunning natural beauty.
The island is a diver’s paradise, with underwater pinnacles and coral walls that Jacques Cousteau reportedly called some of the best diving spots in the world. Most visitors are amazed to discover that Saba has no beaches at all — instead, you’ll find crystal-clear waters perfect for diving and snorkeling right off the rocky coastline.
Bequia
Part of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Bequia feels like stepping back in time to when the Caribbean moved at a gentler pace. The island stretches about 7 miles long and maintains a strong maritime tradition, with local boat builders still crafting vessels using techniques passed down through generations.
Princess Margaret Beach offers powdery white sand and calm turquoise waters that rival any postcard scene. The main town of Port Elizabeth buzzes with friendly locals who genuinely seem happy to share their slice of paradise with visitors.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Montserrat
Known as the ‘Emerald Isle of the Caribbean,’ Montserrat offers a unique blend of Irish heritage and Caribbean culture that you won’t find anywhere else. The island’s southern half remains off-limits due to an active volcano, which might sound scary but actually creates some of the most dramatic and beautiful landscapes in the region.
Black sand beaches formed from volcanic activity provide a striking contrast to the lush green hills. Visitors often describe feeling like they’re exploring a living geology textbook, with steaming vents and mineral-rich hot springs scattered throughout the accessible areas.
Anegada
This flat coral island stands out among the mountainous British Virgin Islands like a pancake in a pile of rocks. Anegada sits surrounded by one of the largest coral reefs in the Caribbean, creating shallow turquoise waters that seem to glow from within.
The island is famous for its lobster fishing, and local restaurants serve up some of the freshest seafood you’ll ever taste. With a population of just 300 people, you’re more likely to encounter flamingos and rock iguanas than other tourists during your visit.
Carriacou
This charming island between Grenada and St. Vincent moves to the rhythm of traditional boat-building and fishing communities. Carriacou measures just 13 square miles, but it packs an impressive variety of landscapes from rolling hills to pristine beaches with sand so fine it squeaks under your feet. The island maintains strong cultural traditions, including the Big Drum ceremony that blends African, French, and British influences into something uniquely Caribbean.
Local festivals here feel authentic rather than tourist-focused, giving visitors a genuine taste of Caribbean island life.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Salt Cay
Part of the Turks and Caicos, Salt Cay feels like a forgotten corner of the world where time moves differently. The island’s economy once revolved around salt production, and you can still see the remains of old salt pans that created the wealth of this tiny speck of land.
Today, fewer than 100 people call Salt Cay home, making it one of the most peaceful places in the Caribbean. Humpback whales migrate past the island between January and April, creating some of the best whale watching opportunities in the region.
Culebra
This Puerto Rican island sanctuary combines stunning natural beauty with a laid-back vibe that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Culebra National Wildlife Refuge protects much of the island, ensuring that development remains minimal and wildlife thrives. Flamenco Beach regularly appears on lists of the world’s most beautiful beaches, with blindingly white sand and water so clear you can see tropical fish swimming from the shore.
The island has no chain restaurants or big resorts — just small family-run guesthouses and local eateries that serve fresh fish caught that morning.
Dominica
Often called ‘The Nature Island,’ Dominica offers a completely different Caribbean experience focused on rainforests, waterfalls, and volcanic peaks rather than beaches. The island contains 365 rivers, creating countless swimming spots and some of the most spectacular waterfalls you’ll ever see. Sperm whales live in the deep waters off Dominica year-round, making it one of the best places in the world for whale watching.
Adventure seekers love the hiking trails that lead through pristine rainforest to hidden hot springs and boiling lakes that showcase the island’s volcanic activity.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Anguilla
This long, thin island stretches like a sleeping lizard in the sun, offering 33 pristine beaches that rarely feel crowded. Anguilla has managed to maintain an upscale but understated atmosphere, attracting visitors who appreciate luxury without the flashiness found on other islands.
The local restaurant scene punches well above its weight, with world-class chefs creating innovative dishes using fresh local ingredients. Shoal Bay East consistently ranks among the Caribbean’s top beaches, with sand so white it almost hurts your eyes and water that shifts between impossible shades of blue and green.
Barbuda
This flat coral island offers a Robinson Crusoe experience just 30 miles north of bustling Antigua. Barbuda’s 17-mile Pink Beach gets its unusual color from tiny coral fragments mixed with white sand, creating a soft rose hue that’s particularly striking at sunset. The island hosts one of the largest frigate bird colonies in the Caribbean, with thousands of these magnificent seabirds nesting in the mangroves.
With only about 1,600 residents, Barbuda feels like a place where everyone knows everyone, and visitors quickly become part of the extended community.
Marie-Galante
This round French island moves to a slower rhythm than its neighbors Guadeloupe and Martinique. Marie-Galante is famous for producing some of the Caribbean’s finest rum, with several distilleries still using traditional windmills and copper stills.
The island’s beaches stretch for miles without a building in sight, giving you the feeling of having discovered your own private paradise. Local markets overflow with tropical fruits you’ve probably never heard of, and the Creole cuisine here represents some of the most authentic French Caribbean cooking you’ll find anywhere.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Tobago Cays
This collection of five small uninhabited islands creates a natural aquarium in the southern Grenadines. The Tobago Cays Marine Park protects the coral reefs and turtle nesting sites, ensuring that the underwater world remains as pristine as it was centuries ago.
You can literally swim with sea turtles in the shallow lagoons between the islands — an experience that feels magical no matter how many times you do it. Day boats from other islands bring visitors for snorkeling and picnicking, but by late afternoon, you often have these tropical gems entirely to yourself.
Jost Van Dyke
This small British Virgin Island embodies the laid-back Caribbean lifestyle that seems to be disappearing elsewhere. The famous Soggy Dollar Bar claims to be the birthplace of the Painkiller cocktail, and whether that’s true or not, they certainly make a mean one.
Great Harbour offers excellent snorkeling right off the beach, with colorful coral formations and tropical fish just a few kicks from shore. The entire island has a population of less than 300, creating an intimate atmosphere where bar owners remember your drink order and boat captains wave like old friends.
Petit St. Vincent
This private island resort in the Grenadines offers the ultimate in Caribbean seclusion and luxury. The entire island spans just 113 acres, with 22 individual cottages scattered along pristine beaches and hillsides.
Guests communicate with staff using a unique flag system — raise a yellow flag for service, red for privacy, and no flag means you’re happy to chat. The island has no phones, televisions, or internet in the rooms, encouraging a complete digital detox that many visitors find surprisingly liberating.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Union Island
patrick_nouhailler/Known as the ‘Tahiti of the West Indies,’ Union Island combines dramatic mountain peaks with excellent sailing and diving opportunities. The island serves as a hub for exploring the southern Grenadines, with water taxis and small planes connecting to even more remote destinations.
Happy Island, an artificial island built entirely from conch shells, sits in the harbor and serves cold drinks with a side of quirky Caribbean ingenuity. Local Rastafarian culture influences much of the island’s art, music, and cuisine, creating a unique blend of Caribbean and African traditions.
Palm Island
This privately owned resort island was transformed from a swampy, mosquito-infested piece of land into a tropical paradise through decades of careful cultivation. The island’s five beaches offer different experiences, from calm lagoon swimming to world-class windsurfing depending on your mood.
Coconut palms planted over 40 years ago now tower over the resort, creating natural shade and that classic Caribbean ambiance. The transformation story of Palm Island proves that with vision and persistence, even the most unlikely places can become paradise.
Beyond the Beaten Path
These hidden Caribbean islands remind us that paradise doesn’t always come with a crowd. While popular destinations certainly have their appeal, these lesser-known gems offer something increasingly rare in our connected world — the chance to truly disconnect and experience the Caribbean as it was meant to be. Each island maintains its own character and charm, proving that the best travel experiences often happen when you venture beyond the guidebook recommendations.
The next time you’re planning a Caribbean getaway, consider trading the familiar for the extraordinary.
More from Travel Pug
- 20 Best Beach Towns in the Carolinas
- 13 Destinations Where Tourists Regularly Regret Their Trip
- 20 Things You Actually Get in First Class
- 20 Small Airports With Aviation Museums
- 20 Places in the U.S. That Are Perfect for a Reset Trip
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.