South America’s colonial history lives on in hundreds of remarkably preserved cities and towns established during three centuries of Spanish and Portuguese rule. While Cartagena, Cusco, and Buenos Aires appear in most travel itineraries, the continent harbors countless lesser-known colonial settlements where cobblestone streets, whitewashed churches, and ornate mansions remain largely unchanged since their 16th, 17th, and 18th-century heydays.
Here is a list of 20 hidden colonial-era cities across South America where visitors can experience authentic historical ambiance while exploring urban landscapes that truly feel frozen in time.
Villa de Leyva, Colombia
Norman Island in the British Virgin Islands has a documented incident from 1750 when sailors from a Spanish vessel concealed a portion of valuable cargo there. British colonial records mention the island primarily as a navigational reference point in official maritime charts.
The western shore caves are natural formations continuously used as shelters by various vessels throughout the region’s naval history.
Tobago’s Northeast Coast
In Dutch, French, and British colonial records, Tobago’s northeastern shoreline appears as the site of multiple territorial disputes during the 17th and 18th centuries. Historical maps from the period mark various bays along this coastline for their freshwater sources and timber resources.
Colonial accounts document the island changing hands between European powers at least 31 times, making it one of the most contested territories in Caribbean colonial history.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Port Royal
Port Royal in Jamaica is extensively documented in historical records as a significant English colonial port that served as a base for privateers operating with letters of marque from the British crown. Archaeological excavations have recovered over 300,000 artifacts from the submerged portion of the city following the 1692 earthquake that sank much of the settlement.
Contemporary accounts describe Port Royal as a bustling commercial center where officially sanctioned privateers like Henry Morgan returned with captured Spanish goods authorized through prize courts.
Bahamian Maritime Routes
Naval archives feature the Bahamian archipelago as a strategically significant maritime corridor connecting the Caribbean to the Atlantic. Historical records document the region’s extensive use for wrecking (salvaging shipwrecks), a legal profession often mischaracterized as piracy in later accounts.
Colonial-era navigation charts mark numerous small cays and passages as landmarks for legitimate maritime traffic navigating the challenging waters.
Yucatán Peninsula Coastal Settlements
Mexico’s Yucatán Peninsula coast, including Isla Mujeres, is archaeologically documented as containing Maya settlements and later colonial trading posts. Historical records from the 19th century confirm that wealthy merchant Fermin Mundaca developed a substantial hacienda on Isla Mujeres, with architectural remains still visible today.
Spanish and Mexican archives document the region’s significance in the legitimate logwood trade, which was economically vital to the colonial maritime economy.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
British Virgin Islands Naval History
The British Virgin Islands appear extensively in Royal Navy records as strategic locations for monitoring maritime traffic through the region. Historical documents confirm the construction of official signal stations and lookout points on various headlands throughout the island group.
Archaeological surveys have uncovered colonial-era anchoring equipment at multiple bays, confirming their use as regular harbors for authorized shipping.
Dominica Military Installations
Dominica’s Scotts Head peninsula contains verified archaeological remains of 18th-century British military fortifications built as part of official colonial defense systems. Historical records document the strategic significance of this location during the Anglo-French conflicts that characterized the Caribbean geopolitics of the period.
British military correspondence from the late 1700s confirms the stationing of official troops and cannons at this location to monitor the passage between Dominica and Martinique.
Cooper Island Harbor
Cooper Island in the British Virgin Islands appears in colonial-era maritime charts as a designated anchorage with fresh water and timber sources. Botanical records document the presence of manchineel trees throughout the region, which naturalists have noted for their toxic properties used in maritime applications.
Historical accounts mention the bay as one of many regular stopping points for inter-island trading vessels engaged in legitimate commerce.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Cayman Islands Maritime Economy
Little Cayman appears in historical records primarily for its significance in the turtle fishing industry, which supplied provisions to passing vessels. Colonial-era accounts document the island’s role in providing resources to British naval vessels and merchant ships operating legally in the region.
Marine geological surveys confirm the dramatic underwater topography that makes the area environmentally distinct rather than having specific connections to illicit activities.
St. Croix Colonial Heritage
St. Croix’s Salt River Bay has been extensively documented for its historical significance. Archaeological evidence confirms Columbus’s arrival in 1493 and subsequent European settlement. Danish colonial records detail the bay’s role in legitimate agricultural trade, particularly sugar production from the surrounding plantations.
The mangrove ecosystem has remained largely unchanged since the colonial period, when naturalist accounts noted its ecological significance.
Belize Barrier Reef Navigation
Historical records document the Belize barrier reef system, including small islands like Tobacco Caye, as significant navigational challenges mapped by official colonial surveys. British colonial correspondence mentions these locations primarily for their importance in the legitimate logwood and mahogany trade, which was essential to the region’s economy.
Navigational charts from the 18th century mark these areas with detailed soundings to guide authorized shipping through the challenging reef system.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Virgin Gorda Geological Features
The Baths on Virgin Gorda appear in colonial-era accounts primarily as notable geological formations documented by naturalists and surveyors. Archaeological investigations have found evidence of pre-Columbian Arawak usage of the site rather than colonial-era activities.
British naval charts mark the distinctive boulder formations as significant landmarks for legitimate regional navigation.
Tortola Coastal Settlements
Western Tortola’s coastal areas are documented in colonial records as sites of legitimate agricultural activity, particularly focused on sugar production. Historical maps from the British colonial period mark various bays as designated ports of entry where customs officials monitored commercial traffic.
Archaeological evidence reveals the remains of colonial-era plantations rather than any significant maritime smuggling infrastructure.
British Virgin Islands Navigation Markers
The rock formations known as The Indians near Norman Island appear in official British naval charts as designated navigation markers for all authorized shipping in the region. Historical accounts mention these distinctive pillars in legitimate sailing directions published for merchant vessels traversing these waters.
Geological surveys confirm these formations as natural rather than human-made structures, with no evidence of modifications for clandestine purposes.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Jamaica’s Naval Significance
Kingston Harbor in Jamaica is extensively documented in British naval archives as a strategically vital base for official Royal Navy operations in the Caribbean. Historical records confirm Henry Morgan’s role as Lieutenant Governor of Jamaica after receiving official knighthood, operating entirely within legal British colonial authority.
Archaeological excavations in the Port Royal area have uncovered extensive evidence of the settlement’s legitimate commercial activities alongside its naval significance.
St. Vincent and the Grenadines Maritime Trade
The Grenadines archipelago, including Canouan Island, appears in colonial records primarily for its role in legitimate inter-island trade networks. Historical accounts document these harbors as regular stopping points for authorized trading vessels carrying agricultural products between colonial possessions.
French and British colonial correspondence mentions these locations mainly in the context of official territorial disputes rather than illicit activities.
St. Lucia’s Natural Harbors
Marigot Bay on St. Lucia appears in French and British colonial records as a significant natural harbor noted for its protection against tropical storms. Historical naval charts mark the bay’s narrow entrance and deep basin as advantageous for legitimate maritime activities.
Colonial correspondence documents the bay’s use by official vessels during the numerous times the island changed hands between European powers.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Jost Van Dyke Settlement History
Jost Van Dyke in the British Virgin Islands appears in colonial records primarily for its small-scale agricultural settlements rather than maritime significance. Historical accounts document the island’s development as a center for legitimate sugar production during the British colonial period.
Archaeological surveys have uncovered the remains of colonial-era structures related to agricultural processing rather than maritime activities.
Tobago’s Colonial Conflicts
Naval records document Tobago’s various bays as sites of official military engagements between European powers competing for colonial control. Historical archives contain detailed accounts of at least 31 documented transfers of the island between different colonial authorities.
Archaeological investigations have uncovered multiple military fortifications that confirm the island’s significance in legitimate colonial conflicts rather than pirate activities.
Montserrat’s Geological History
Montserrat’s eastern shoreline appears in colonial records primarily in the context of the island’s significant volcanic activity and agricultural development. Historical accounts document the region’s legitimate trade in sugar, rum, and cotton produced on established plantations.
Geological surveys confirm the natural volcanic origin of the distinctive black sand beaches formed through well-documented geological processes.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Maritime History: Separating Fact from Fiction
Archaeological evidence and primary historical documents provide a picture of Caribbean maritime history based on verifiable facts rather than romantic legends. Historical research distinguishes between privateers operating with legal commissions and the much less common true pirates, with most ‘pirate coves’ showing no archaeological evidence of such usage.
Modern tourism emphasizes pirate connections that historical evidence does not support, as cultural mythology has become more economically significant than the region’s documented maritime past.
More from Travel Pug
- 20 Towns Built for One Purpose That Were Later Abandoned
- 15 Hidden Spots in Disney World’s Magic Kingdom Most Visitors Miss
- 20 Once-Popular Beach Towns That Are Now Ghostly Empty
- 15 Canyons in the U.S. That Are Just as Stunning as the Grand Canyon
- 10 Under-the-Radar Mountain Towns That Are Both Affordable and Beautiful
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.