The phrase ‘private island’ typically conjures images of celebrity hideaways with astronomical price tags, yet numerous islands around the world offer the exclusive experience without requiring a millionaire’s budget. These secluded retreats provide the ultimate escape from crowds and noise, allowing travelers to experience the unique luxury of having an entire island to themselves.
Here is a list of 15 affordable private islands you can actually rent—proving that this seemingly extravagant vacation option might be more accessible than you’d imagine.
Bird Island, Belize
Just a 20-minute boat ride from Placencia, Belize, this tiny coral island offers complete privacy for up to six guests at around $595 per night. The colorful one-acre retreat comes with a fully equipped house featuring wraparound decks perfectly positioned for sunrise and sunset views.
Guests enjoy complimentary use of kayaks and snorkeling equipment to explore the surrounding Caribbean waters teeming with marine life. The island’s caretakers stock the kitchen before arrival, but otherwise leave visitors completely alone—creating the authentic feeling of having discovered your tropical paradise.
Ilha Grande, Brazil
This island retreat off Brazil’s Green Coast offers accommodation for up to eight people starting at just $300 per night, making it remarkably affordable when costs are shared. Located within a protected marine reserve, the property includes a charming main house nestled among palm trees with direct beach access and spectacular views across crystal-clear waters.
Guests can explore nearby islands using the included motorboat or simply relax in hammocks strung between palms while watching for passing dolphins. The island strikes a perfect balance between rustic authenticity and comfortable amenities—including solar power, freshwater showers, and a surprisingly reliable internet connection.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Hvaler Islands, Norway
Nestled in Norway’s Oslo Fjord, these private islands offer Scandinavian summer cottages from $200 per night, providing affordable access to pristine Nordic landscapes. Traditional red wooden houses sit atop smooth granite outcroppings, surrounded by crystal-clear waters ideal for swimming during the surprisingly warm summer months.
The lengthy Nordic summer days provide nearly 20 hours of daylight, allowing guests to maximize their outdoor experiences, from morning fishing trips to midnight beach bonfires. Many properties include traditional wooden saunas where visitors can partake in the quintessential Nordic experience of alternating between steamy heat and refreshing dips in the surrounding fjord.
Dunbar Rock, Honduras
This remarkable villa, built atop a private rocky outcrop, accommodates up to 16 guests for approximately $250 per person per night, including meals and some activities. Rising dramatically from turquoise Caribbean waters near the island of Guanaja, the Spanish-style villa appears to float above the sea at high tide.
Visitors enjoy world-class scuba diving directly from the island’s dock, accessing pristine reef systems just minutes away by boat. The all-inclusive pricing becomes particularly reasonable for groups, offering access to facilities typically found at luxury resorts—including freshwater infinity pools overlooking the Caribbean and professional chefs preparing local seafood caught daily.
Shelter Island, Canada
Located in rural Nova Scotia, this 5-acre wooded island rents for around $275 per night and accommodates up to eight guests in a charming lakeside cabin. The island sits within a freshwater lake surrounded by undeveloped wilderness, offering complete privacy and silence broken only by calling loons and splashing fish.
Visitors access the property via a short canoe paddle, immediately creating the sensation of leaving conventional vacations behind. The rustic-yet-comfortable cabin includes modern amenities alongside traditional features like a wood-burning stove and a covered porch ideal for watching storms roll across the lake.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Brother Island, Philippines
This one-acre tropical paradise in the El Nido region accommodates up to 12 guests at approximately $450 per night for the entire island. The traditional Filipino beach house comes staffed with caretakers who prepare fresh local cuisine while otherwise respecting guests’ privacy across the palm-covered property.
Visitors enjoy exclusive access to white sand beaches wrapped around the entire island, with world-class snorkeling directly offshore among coral gardens and abundant marine life. The island’s location within the spectacularly beautiful Bacuit Archipelago means that guests can arrange outrigger boat trips to explore hidden lagoons and secluded beaches scattered throughout the surrounding islands.
Crescent Island, Florida
Just 90 minutes from Orlando, this two-acre freshwater island offers surprisingly affordable seclusion at around $350 per night for up to eight guests. The property features a comfortable main house surrounded by ancient cypress trees draped with Spanish moss, creating a quintessentially Southern atmosphere.
Guests enjoy exclusive use of boats, fishing equipment, and water toys included with the rental, perfect for exploring the surrounding chain of lakes. Evening gatherings around the lakeside fire pit offer perfect star-gazing opportunities—a forgotten luxury for most urban dwellers visiting Florida’s more developed tourist areas.
Urraca Island, Panama
Located within Panama’s pristine Bocas del Toro archipelago, this eco-friendly island resort offers private cabanas built over the water starting at just $150 per night. The property operates as a small resort rather than a whole-island rental, yet its limited capacity and thoughtful layout ensure substantial privacy for each guest.
Visitors access their accommodations via wooden walkways suspended above coral reefs, with ladders leading directly from private decks into the Caribbean below. The island’s restaurant specializes in sustainably caught seafood and locally grown produce, creating sophisticated meals that rival much pricier destinations.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Ilha do Japão, Brazil
Situated in Brazil’s stunning Angra dos Reis region, this island paradise accommodates up to 14 guests for approximately $900 per night—reasonable when divided among multiple couples or families. The main house features traditional Brazilian architecture with abundant outdoor living spaces designed to maximize the tropical setting and cooling ocean breezes.
Guests enjoy access to multiple beaches, hiking trails through Atlantic rainforest vegetation, and crystal-clear waters ideal for snorkeling around the island’s perimeter. The property comes staffed with caretakers who prepare regional cuisine featuring freshly caught seafood and locally grown tropical fruits.
Sweet Island, Nicaragua
Nestled within Lake Nicaragua, this affordable island retreat costs around $250 per night and accommodates up to 10 guests in a spacious lake house. The two-acre property offers spectacular views of the Concepción volcano rising dramatically from nearby Ometepe Island—especially stunning during sunrise and sunset.
Hammocks strung between mango trees provide perfect reading spots, while the surrounding freshwater lake offers swimming without concerns about currents or dangerous marine life. The island’s location, just a 10-minute boat ride from the colonial town of Granada, allows visitors to combine private island seclusion with easy access to restaurants, markets, and cultural attractions.
Rainbow Island, Canada
This 3-acre private retreat in Ontario’s Thousand Islands region rents for approximately $300 per night and comfortably houses up to six guests. The charming cottage features wraparound decks practically hovering over the St. Lawrence River, providing prime spots for watching massive ships navigate the seaway just yards from your morning coffee spot.
Visitors enjoy exclusive use of kayaks and a motorboat for exploring the labyrinth of nearby islands—many still undeveloped and perfect for picnic excursions. Evening bonfires on the island’s private dock offer stunning sunset views while the river reflects the changing colors across perfectly still waters.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Motu Teta, French Polynesia
While pushing the upper limits of ‘affordable,’ this remarkable Tahitian island offers an authentic South Pacific experience for around $4,000 per night—accommodating up to 10 guests, making the per-person cost comparable to luxury hotels in the region. The property includes traditional thatched bungalows built using ancient Polynesian techniques, scattered across a picture-perfect palm-covered paradise surrounded by the turquoise lagoon of Rangiroa Atoll.
Visitors enjoy completely personalized service from resident staff who prepare gourmet meals featuring just-caught fish and produce from the island’s organic gardens. The extraordinarily remote location—accessed via private boat transfer from an already remote airport—ensures complete privacy among some of Earth’s most spectacular scenery.
King Island, Belize
Located inside Belize’s Barrier Reef, this tiny mangrove island offers rustic accommodation for up to four guests at approximately $200 per night. The property features a traditional stilted cabana built directly over crystal-clear waters, connected to the small island by wooden walkways winding through mangrove forests.
Visitors prepare meals in the well-equipped outdoor kitchen using fresh ingredients brought from the mainland or fish caught around the island’s perimeter. The reef location provides exceptional snorkeling opportunities directly from the property, with vibrant coral formations and abundant marine life just feet from the ladder leading into the Caribbean.
Dolphin Jump Key, Florida
This four-acre island in the Florida Keys rents for around $550 per night, accommodating up to eight guests in a charming waterfront cottage with old Florida charm. The property sits within a protected nature reserve accessible only by boat, ensuring privacy while remaining just minutes from Marathon’s restaurants and services.
Visitors enjoy exceptional fishing directly from the island’s dock, with tarpon, permit, and bonefish frequenting the surrounding flats—often accompanied by passing dolphins that inspired the island’s name. The screened porch wrapping around three sides of the house provides perfect bug-free outdoor living space for enjoying spectacular sunset views over the Gulf of Mexico.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Marooned Island, Norway
Situated within Norway’s spectacular Lofoten archipelago, this remote island cabin rents for around $200 per night and accommodates up to six adventurous travelers. The property offers rustic comfort amid world-class scenery—with dramatic mountain peaks rising directly from the Norwegian Sea just across the protected channel.
Visitors access the island via a short boat transfer, then spend days hiking across rolling meadows, fishing from rocky shores, or simply watching for sea eagles from the cabin’s panoramic windows. The legendary midnight sun during summer months means outdoor activities can continue around the clock—perfect for photographers capturing the extraordinary arctic light that has drawn artists to this region for centuries.
Islands Within Reach
The growing market for affordable island rentals has democratized what was once the ultimate exclusive escape, allowing travelers with modest budgets to experience the unmatched privacy of having an entire island to themselves.
These properties typically emphasize authentic connection with natural surroundings rather than opulent luxury, creating experiences that feel genuine rather than ostentatious. Savvy travelers have discovered that by sharing costs among friends or family, these seemingly extravagant getaways often cost less per person than standard resort accommodations—while providing infinitely more memorable experiences.
More from Travel Pug
- 20 Towns Built for One Purpose That Were Later Abandoned
- 15 Hidden Spots in Disney World’s Magic Kingdom Most Visitors Miss
- 20 Once-Popular Beach Towns That Are Now Ghostly Empty
- 15 Canyons in the U.S. That Are Just as Stunning as the Grand Canyon
- 10 Under-the-Radar Mountain Towns That Are Both Affordable and Beautiful
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.