The UK’s longest-standing debate between most populated cities continues to baffle tourists. London blinds the whole city with famous landmarks and constant fun, whereas Edinburgh invites tourists with medieval structures and a heavy atmosphere. Both cities are fantastic, but depending on your type of tour, one will feel like your perfect match.
Below are 20 reasons why London or Edinburgh may be better suited to your travel style. Use them to decide which UK city is worth your visit on your next vacation.
Size and Scale
London sprawls across 607 square miles with a population exceeding 9 million – creating an urban landscape that’ll take weeks to explore properly. Edinburgh, by comparison, covers just 102 square miles with fewer than 500,000 residents, making for a more manageable experience where you can walk between major attractions in minutes instead of requiring multiple transit connections.
Walkability
Edinburgh’s densely populated city center means you can walk from Edinburgh Castle to Holyrood Palace down the Royal Mile in less than an hour, stopping at numerous attractions en route. London requires meticulous planning and utilizing public transport, as walking between major attractions such as the Tower of London and Buckingham Palace would take up most of your day and exhaust you.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Transportation Costs
London’s transport system, as comprehensive as it is, is more costly—a one-week 1-2 zone travel card runs about £37, and singles soon add up for tourists. Edinburgh’s public transportation needs are minimal for most tourists—a day’s bus passes cost barely more than £4.50, perhaps saving tourists a huge amount of money that can be spent on experiences rather than transport.
Architectural Character
Edinburgh possesses a remarkably cohesive architectural personality in its medieval Old Town and Georgian New Town – both UNESCO World Heritage sites that create a visually cohesive experience. London offers an eclectic assortment that ranges from ancient Roman walls to Norman fortresses, medieval churches, Georgian terraces, Victorian pomp and circumstance, and ultra-modern skyscrapers all mixed into its sprawling landscape.
Green Spaces
London boasts beautiful royal parks like Hyde Park and Regent’s Park scattered around the city – providing elegance from the urban grind. Edinburgh has tougher natural adventures within city limits; humping Arthur’s Seat rewards you with a 360-degree view from a 251-million-year-old extinct volcano within a short walk of the Royal Mile.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Museum Density
London has top-notch museums like the British Museum, National Gallery, Victoria and Albert Museum, and Natural History Museum—all within close walking distance and free to attend. Edinburgh museums, though good, are not as numerous but more centralized, like the National Museum of Scotland and Writers’ Museum, so that individuals can come without the museum-induced exhaustion.
Cultural Diversity
London is as cosmopolitan a city as there is in the world, with over 300 languages spoken and cultural enclaves from nearly every nation displayed in its restaurants, festivals, and neighborhood character. Edinburgh, though becoming increasingly globalized, retains a more Scottish cultural dominance throughout the city, providing travelers with a stronger sense of Scottish culture and traditions.
Food Scene
London’s culinary culture has over 70 Michelin-starred restaurants and unlimited world cuisines of all price points, with whole neighborhoods dedicated to one world flavor or another. Edinburgh’s diminutive but aggressive food culture has grown impressively with high-quality Scottish farm-to-table dishes, fresh seafood, and innovative local chefs innovating with local ingredients in traditional as well as modern preparations.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Weather Patterns
Edinburgh has stronger seasons with colder winter temperatures, whereas its coastal location means the conditions change rapidly. Locals tend to joke that you can experience all four seasons in a single day.
London is slightly warmer all year, with approximately 106 rainy days annually compared to Edinburgh’s 124, and London’s summer temperatures tend to be a couple of degrees warmer.
Festival Atmosphere
Edinburgh transforms during August when the Fringe Festival brings over 3,000 shows and triples the city’s population, creating an unmatched atmosphere of creative energy and round-the-clock entertainment. London hosts major events throughout the year, from Notting Hill Carnival to Winter Wonderland.
Still, they typically occupy specific areas rather than transforming the entire city atmosphere as Edinburgh’s festivals do.
Accommodation Costs
London is always among the world’s most costly cities for lodging, with average hotel rooms costing more than £150 per night and budget lodgings usually requiring serious compromise on quality or location. Edinburgh is less expensive for accommodations during non-festival times, with decent-located guesthouses and B&Bs costing £70-100, although they triple in cost during major August events.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Historical Layers
Edinburgh’s past is still apparent in a relatively small area, with medieval Old Town and 18th-century New Town side by side, making it simpler to grasp the historical context. London’s two-millennium history of development in a vast area, with Roman, medieval, Tudor, Stuart, Georgian, Victorian, and contemporary periods scattered over different neighborhoods, entails more background to grasp and appreciate.
Coastal Proximity
Edinburgh is only a few minutes from the scenic Firth of Forth coast, and beaches like Portobello and charming fishing ports like South Queensferry are accessible by short bus rides. London requires longer journeys of a minimum of 60-90 minutes to reach coastal towns like Brighton or Southend, making spontaneous beach excursions less easily accessible for people with limited time.
Day Trip Options
Edinburgh is a good base from which to see the Scottish Highlands, and pretty spots like Loch Lomond, St. Andrews, and Stirling Castle are within 1-2 hours by bus or train. London offers equivalent day trip opportunities to Windsor Castle, Oxford, Cambridge, or Bath.
Still, these excursions tend to involve a longer travel time because distances are greater and there are traffic problems.
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.
Shopping Experiences
London has an unrivaled variety of shopping in top-end department stores such as Harrods and Selfridges, giant chains like Oxford Street’s, specialist territories like Savile Row, and more offbeat areas like Borough and Portobello Road. Edinburgh’s shopping center is centered along Princes Street and the Royal Mile.
However, independently-owned small shops in other areas like Grassmarket and Stockbridge selling Scottish motifs, woolly equipment, and local-made items are found in smaller proportions in less rowdy climates.
The Decisive Factor
Both cities deliver superlative experiences that have been captivating visitors for centuries. They both keep their own identities while adapting to contemporary norms.
London is for those who are high on boundless possibility and around-the-clock activity, and Edinburgh is best suited for travelers who prefer full-blooded experiences in a slightly more compact context where heritage and landscape remain within effortless reach.
More from Travel Pug
- 20 Destinations That Were Once Thriving but Are Now Quietly Disappearing
- 13 Destinations Where Tourists Regularly Regret Their Trip
- 20 Once-Popular Beach Towns That Are Now Ghostly Empty
- 10 Under-the-Radar Mountain Towns That Are Both Affordable and Beautiful
- Take a ‘Learning Vacation’ in These 20 Extraordinary Places
Like Travel Pug’s content? Follow us on MSN.